So I added my new favorite thing: BLACK SPRAY PAINT!
I covered the block letters in mod podge and stuck on the craft paper. I let it dry and then cut around the letter's edges with an ex-acto knife. I sanded them down a bit and left them distressed. Then I glued them to some craft paper that would make them pop out of the frame. I have some rub on letters that I added to the corners of the letter to add some detailing.
I had to do the frames length-wise because the W was too wide to fit in it the other way.Not too shabby. I am excited to show them to her and see how they look on the wall!